Several years ago, I was asked to serve as one of the first-round judges for the Writer’s Digest Annual International Self-Published Book Awards contest, specifically for the “life stories” category.
While I recognize that there are some fine writers who have self-published books (some even went on to become famous authors), I knew that all of the wanna-be-writers (polished and unpolished alike) would be represented in this contest, which meant I could end up with daily migraines for the better part of a month. That’s why I hedged a bit with my decision. And when I added the fact that my compensation for this task would be little more than nothing, I wasn’t sure if I wanted to do it at all.
But, in the end, I agreed. I felt like the experience itself would hold some value for me, and, as an author who has been blessed by God and a few editors, I believe it is my duty to give back to the writing community in one way or another. Maybe I would find a gem or two in this task.
A few days later, a box of 26 books arrived, along with my judging criteria. After reading each book, I was to fill out an evaluation sheet answering the following questions: 1) What impressed you most about the book? and 2) What one thing could be changed to improve the book’s commercial success?
Finally, I was to only return my top picks, listed in order of preference. The top picks should be both impressive and marketable. These would go on to the next round of judging. While there were no limits on how many books could be returned, “three or four” was mentioned several times during email exchanges with the folks at Writer’s Digest.
I went to work immediately. And I took my work quite seriously, placing myself in the shoes of all those who had spent $100 (quite hefty, if you ask me) to enter the contest, entrusting their precious words to the eyes of a stranger.
Some of the books were written about fascinating characters. Space doesn’t allow me to name all of them, but I can’t forget Hube Yates, a remarkable and colorful man. Yates may not go down in any official book as a “great man in history,” but the life he lived, the deeds he performed, and the spirit with which he faced challenges makes him a “great man in history” nonetheless.
I was pleased that some of the authors proved to be excellent writers. In her book Dear Mom: Remembering Our Mothers, Patricia Jana Hassler’s descriptive writing captivated me, its rhythms and sounds providing rich images. Almost every page contained at least one jewel, and I cited a couple of them in my evaluation of the book. Like this one describing Hassler’s great-grandfather’s appearance in a photograph: He is a distinguished man whose ears bend away like great question marks from his bald head. And this one from the Introduction: It is consoling to connect the dots of experience and watch patterns appear.
In all, I ended up with eight top picks, which seemed like a lot, but I felt strongly about each of them, and felt they deserved a shot at the next round.
My top choice was a book entitled, Taking the Stairs by Julie McKown. With a few exceptions, I liked everything about the book. "McKown is an exceptionally gifted writer," I wrote in my evaluation. "Her word pictures and analogies were brilliant, and she reached deep into the soul of the reader, touching the most secret places. It was a trip down a path of healing and self-discovery, and the reader felt every remarkable bump in the road."
I was happy to see that this book won an honorable mention in the final tally. Not bad, considering more than 2,000 books were submitted in all.
In the end, what impressed me most about the books I read was the passion of the authors, and their tenacity at putting words to paper. It isn’t easy, but having such stories in printed form is a priceless gift for future generations.
Have you ever considered that the stories of your life will die with you, unless you document them somewhere? No one else has the stories that you have. They are yours alone, and only you can tell them. Writing them down is one sure way of keeping them safe. And you need not be a great writer. You need only write.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~